The difference and comparison of aluminum alloy and magnesium alloy

Mar 07, 2022

The difference and comparison between aluminum alloy and magnesium alloy are as follows:

1. Description of tensile strength: The strength of the frame made of magnesium alloy material of the same volume is not as strong as that of aluminum alloy. To achieve the strength of the frame, the thickness of the material and the diameter of the tube must be increased. Therefore, from the perspective of weight, magnesium alloy has nothing to do with aluminum alloy. Advantage.

2. Description of metal oxidation: It is clearly shown on the periodic table of elements that magnesium alloys are easier to be oxidized and corroded than aluminum alloys.

3. Description of fatigue resistance: The durability of the frame made of magnesium alloy material of the same volume is worse than that of the aluminum alloy frame. It is also a fatal disadvantage of magnesium alloys. As the number of times of riding increases, the number of times of stress occurrence is also higher, and the strength will be significantly reduced, and even the life of the frame does not exceed 2-3 years, so professional riders rarely use magnesium alloy frames, if they are used during competitions, It is also calculated that the mileage is replaced by discarding.

4. Description of specific gravity: Magnesium alloys are lighter than aluminum alloys under the same volume conditions, which is the advantage of magnesium alloys.

5. Description of manufacturing cost: Because magnesium alloy is a lively metal, there are higher requirements for manufacturing equipment and environment, resulting in high manufacturing costs, and the cost-effectiveness of the produced bicycle frame is far less than that of the aluminum alloy frame.

6. Description of elastic modulus: The rigidity of the frame made of magnesium alloy material is worse than that of the aluminum alloy frame. The frame made of the same thickness and tube diameter will absorb more pedaling force during actual riding, which will affect the riding efficiency.

Conclusion: Magnesium alloys are currently only used in aerospace, military aircraft and 3C industries because of their low specific gravity and density.